skills/common/pkm/crit/SKILL.md

name, description, disable-model-invocation

name	description	disable-model-invocation
crit	brainstorm with AI using the CRIT framework to generate and evaluate ideas.	true

Purpose

This skill implements the CRIT (Context-Request-Input-Tone) framework for structured brainstorming and idea evaluation. It transforms abstract discussions into concrete, actionable outcomes through systematic analysis and iterative refinement.

Core Workflow

Step 1: Context Analysis

Before generating ideas, establish the foundation:

1. Identify the Core Domain

   • What field, industry, or subject area?
   • What are the key constraints (time, resources, technical limitations)?
   • Who is the target audience and their expertise level?

2. Assess Current State

   • What problems or opportunities exist?
   • What has been tried before (if applicable)?
   • What resources are available?

Completion Criterion: Clear understanding of domain, constraints, and current state documented.

Step 2: Request Clarification

Structure the brainstorming request:

1. Define the Specific Goal

   • What concrete outcome do you want?
   • What success criteria will be used?
   • What is the expected timeline?

2. Gather Input Requirements

   • What information is needed to proceed?
   • What assumptions should be validated?
   • What data or resources are required?

Completion Criterion: Specific goal and input requirements clearly defined.

Step 3: Idea Generation

Generate diverse, high-quality ideas:

1. Divergent Thinking Phase

   • Generate 5-10 initial concepts without judgment
   • Apply different perspectives (technical, business, user experience)
   • Include both obvious and unconventional options

2. Convergent Analysis Phase

   • Evaluate each idea against success criteria
   • Score ideas on feasibility, impact, and alignment
   • Identify patterns and synergies between ideas

Completion Criterion: Minimum 5 distinct ideas generated and evaluated with scores.

Step 4: Iterative Refinement

Improve selected ideas:

1. Select Top Candidates

   • Choose 2-3 ideas with highest potential
   • Detail implementation approach for each
   • Identify risks and mitigation strategies

2. Develop Action Plans

   • Break down into concrete steps
   • Assign priorities and dependencies
   • Define success metrics and checkpoints

Completion Criterion: 2-3 refined ideas with detailed action plans.

Step 5: Tone & Delivery

Adapt communication to the audience:

1. Choose Appropriate Role

   • Subject Matter Expert for technical depth
   • Consultant for strategic guidance
   • Teacher for complex concepts
   • Collaborator for co-creation
   • Analyst for multi-perspective evaluation

2. Structure Response

   • Lead with clear, actionable solutions
   • Organize information logically and concisely
   • Include examples or analogies for clarity
   • Suggest next steps and follow-up questions

Completion Criterion: Response delivered in appropriate tone with clear structure.

Quality Guardrails

• Never generate ideas without clear context and goals
• Always evaluate ideas against defined success criteria
• Maintain transparency about assumptions and limitations
• Encourage iteration and collaboration throughout the process
• Ensure all recommendations are practical and actionable

Trigger Hints

Load this skill when the user asks to:

• Generate ideas for a specific problem or opportunity
• Brainstorm solutions with structured evaluation
• Get expert guidance through systematic analysis
• Develop actionable plans from abstract concepts
• Evaluate multiple approaches to a challenge

Output Format

Return results in this structure:

1. Context Analysis: Documented understanding of domain and constraints
2. Request Clarification: Defined goals and input requirements
3. Idea Generation: List of ideas with evaluation scores
4. Refined Solutions: Detailed action plans for top candidates
5. Next Steps: Suggested follow-up actions and questions

Each section should be clearly labeled and include completion criteria verification.